Maxie’s What If BJ Lived Dream?
Thursday, April 30, 2009
The Was the Episode that Aired February 24th, 2009. I have seen many posts after that episode about how any of what happened in the epsiode made sense. Lulu not believing in love. Lulu and Spinelli not being friends. Johnny being a mob prince and strip join owner. Patrick and Robin not being together. Carly and Patrick being together. Well I looked into it. Trying to make it… well to help those who thought none of it made sense. Truth it if you really look into it most of what was shown does make sense to what would happen if Maxie had died and BJ Lived.
First we will start with Lulu and Spinelli. Their friendship had nothing to do with Maxie being died or Alive so why aren’t they friends. A) Spinelli and Lulu aren’t friends, because the never met trying to clear Sam’s name. Because Carly married Patrick, she never married Sonny. Which means Carly never meant Alcazar. And the Corinthos Alcazar battle for Carly never happened. Sonny never had to sleep with Sam or get her pregnant. Jason never had to take care of her and they never feel in love. Which means Jason and Sam never broke up and slept with Liric and Lorenzo and Ric never framed Sam. So Jason never had to find Spinelli who created the disk and Lulu never got involved. So there for Spinelli and Lulu never meant they way they did and Spinelli never feel in love with the blonde one.
Second Scrubs. How could Maxie being dead effect Patrick and Robin. A) this one isn’t as easy as the first one. But going with what the spoilers say. But Maxie dead and then the year after Robin’s love Stone died. So I figure that they two death so close together really hit Robin hard and kind of made her believe this is no happily ever after. And going on Assuming (I know I should) but she never was with Jason. So she never got the chance to believe that you can have your happy ending. So there for when Scrubs meet it just isn’t what it was and Robin enjoys her life and doesn’t take risk so no one else gets hurt or loses anyone else.. and Patrick just Is who he is and doesn’t care. And very mean about it.
Third Johnny and Lulu. No need to explain how that one didn’t happen. A) But to say There was no Logan. And since there was no Maxie. No bet was made and Lulu never found out and took off and Johnny never picked her up. So using that and going into Johnny the Mob lord and strip join owner. I think he was just a big Mob name because there was no one to show him he was bigger then all this and got sucked into the life style of his family. As for the strip joint. You’ve got me. But I think that because there was no Lulu, Trevor was about to control him and Anthony was still around so put the two together and Johnny becomes the person they want him to be.
Forth Lulu not believing in love. Who can that be? A) When Johnny talks to Lulu about joining the strip joint they get into it and Lulu says she knows people. And Johnny makes a crack about oh the big Luke Spencer who hasn’t been seen or heard from in years. So I believe that her parents marriage falling apart. Wither Luke and Laura’s marriage fell apart or Laura still had her break down, Luke still took off and not having a parent present in your life can effect you. Can make you believe that they didn’t love you enough so you don’t get close to anyone in case they pull the same thing. Not to mention Carly (Lulu’s Cousin) ruined Bobbie’s Marriage to Tony. And Carly Marriage to Patrick it’s hugs and kisses either. So I think the two of those combined made you believe that Love isn’t real. It’s just all made up to make people believe it is. And she doesn’t want to get caught up in that lie or life people around her can’t seem to stand to be in.
Fifth Carly and Patrick. A Big WTF? A) The way I see it is. It kind of goes with when Patrick first came to town. Then again Carly used Patrick to get back at Robin and forget Sonny at times. She still went after him (first time to get him to save Jason)… but my point I can kind of see why Patrick ended up with Carly, because there was a thing there in the real show of how Carly and Patrick were slightly intersted in each other. So when their paths crossed this time they like each other. Carly managed to ruin Bobbie’s marriage to Tony, to get back at her for giving her up. Then she ends up with Patrick and the rest don’t score. So AJ and her never happened so no Micheal… her and Sonny never happened so no Morgan… And she never made friends with Courtney… so not bonding over her death with Jax later to lead to love. in stead lead to a loveless marriage to two people who soon found out that they couldn’t stand each other and got them selfs into a marriage they thought would be good for them.
Sixth Spixie vs Fan treat. A) In my person opinion this episode that was supposed to be a fan treat was more like a way to pimp out Spinelli and Maxie yet again. And truthfully to me that is what brought down the episode so much. If they kept it more to the point of what if BJ had lived then maybe it would of been more enjoyable, but it really seemed like it was just anyone to say Spinelli and Maxie belong together. Which I personal to night believe. I happen to be a fan of them both and I frankly would like to see them with other people who will treat each other right and not let the other person hide behind something. In other words I think Spinelli and Maxie makes great friends (maybe a bit more of great friends if the screentime was brought down a bit).. But I don’t think they are made for each other.
So I am going to leave you with this. This is my over analyzing the episode of Maxie what if Dream. And how I see everything fit into place in what was shown. So you can comment on it and maybe add on or disagree. This is ow I see it all fit into what would of happened if BJ had lived and Maxie had died.
